Monday, April 18, 2011

Educational Philosophy

Traveling Pirate posted a comment the other day about education in Finland. Seems they still value vocational education highly. Actually, they seem to value education in general quite highly. I also received an e-mail from the Chicago Tinkering School the next day. And as these things often go, it had a link to Brightworks, a new school opening in San Francisco. As this was the first I had heard of Brightworks, I clicked on the link and checked it out. On the bottom of their home page are two statements that certainly fit in with my educational philosophy: everything is interesting, we can build anything.

Those two statements seem to be a great foundation on which to build a school. Everything is interesting - somethings are just more interesting than others. And of course our interests are colored by our experiences and how we're introduced to a subject. I've noticed over the years that many high school kids are very close-minded. If it's not exactly what they're interested in on that day, it really doesn't matter what you do, they don't want to hear about it. They limit their learning experiences and end up graduating high school knowing very little about anything.

If you've read this blog for any length of time, you'll know why I identify with the "we can build anything" statement. Because we can. And have. The State of Indiana is currently busy writing laws that are designed to improve public education. The reality is that they are dismantling public education. Instead of focusing legislative reform on removing the impediments to learning, they have decided that it's the union's fault that kids aren't learning. Rather than me rehashing the stupidity of what's going on, let's take a moment and present another scenario.

The little tykes go off to school and they are just tickled to death. They do the original cut and paste, they draw, they sing songs, they do the ABC's, and they learn because everything is interesting. As they age and work through the grades, they continue to be exposed to anything that is interesting. That should be easy, everything is interesting. They also continue to build things. They go from gluing cotton ball clouds on construction paper to woodworking, metalworking, photography, bookbinding, leatherworking, gardening, fishing, hiking, you name it -just keep throwing it at them so they are exposed to a variety of stimuli and they are using their developing skills to build things. Any thing. When they graduate from high school they will have been exposed to all kinds of things by pursuing what interested them and what interested their teachers. They will have developed the skills to build all types of things because they built all types of things. They will have used their math concepts, learned some electronics, woodworking, welding, machining, etc., and since they didn't learn these skills and concepts in isolation, they can apply them wherever they fit or as need arises.

The damned concept is so simple, anyone should be able to grasp it. When you're out fishing, you don't have to talk about fish. When you're out hiking, you can talk about geology but you don't have to. Everything is interesting. So let's discuss it. And let's build something to go along with it. Let's build lots and lots of things. Everything is interesting. If you can build anything, you have to know about everything. Really simple. Done properly, it could go a long way to mitigate the effects of poverty, race and other impediments to educational success.

I'm really glad to see there is some movement in the right direction. I'm not sure if Brightworks will be the answer but it's definitely going in the right direction. Finland has been kicking our ass for awhile now and instead of squaring off against them and seeing what we can do to get on top, we look at the thing least likely to make it better and go with that.

So the answers to improving education are out there, it just requires some decent leadership to implement. The state legislature is absolutely clueless as to what they're doing., so they're no help. Instead, just keep the level of interest up and the kids will damn near teach themselves. Blow up all the computers in the buildings unless they are being used as a tool such as part of a CNC milling program. Get the kids outside as much as possible. And put some creative people in charge. People that are interested in everything and can build anything. I know they're out there. Hell, that describes most of my friends and family.

4 comments:

tvi said...

HEY "BOB",

I ASSUME YOU KNEW THIS WOULD GET ME STARTED, HA HA. THE TEACH INTERESTING THINGS PHRASE, IS IN MY HUMBLE OPINION, IS THE MOST BLATANT FAULT OF THE EDUCATION SYSTEM. I AM NOT A TEACHER, I AM JUST A MECHANIC. WHAT I SEE IN MY SON'S FRIENDS IS EXACTLY NO INTEREST IN WHAT THEY ARE LEARNING.

DREW SEEMS TO HAVE A BETTER GRASP OF THIS, BUT EVEN HE TELLS ME IT'S BORING. I THINK THAT(BORROWING DOUG STOWE'S PHRASE) ENGAGE THEIR HANDS TO KEEP THEM INTERESTED. INSTEAD OF DICTATING TO THEM WHAT THEY NEED TO KNOW, IN ORDER TO GET SCHOOL FUNDING, ASK THEM WHAT WOULD BE INTERESTING. I DON'T BELIEVE YOU HAVE TO FOLLOW ALL OF THEIR REQUESTS, BUT IT WOULD AT LEAST BE A PLACE TO START. THE TEACHERS ARE ALSO A PLACE TO ASK, WHAT INTERESTS THEM AND COULD IT BE PUT IN THE CURRICULUM TO ADD THE STUDENTS LEARNING.

THERE HAS TO BE A PLACE TO START, SOME ONE SOMEWHERE HAS TO LISTEN, DON'T THEY?

TALK TO YOU SOON,

TVI

leroy99 said...

Sounds logical, and I can build some stuff too!

Shop Teacher Bob said...

TVI: You and your son are exactly the people they should be asking for input on school improvement. If a sharp kid like Drew is bored with what the school is teaching or with the way it's presented, there is definitely a problem. There was a movie starring Nick Nolte called Teachers,I believe, and the most effective teacher in the school was a guy who had escaped from the looney bin. The governor of Idaho wants everyone in high school to take a minimum of four classes on a computer. Many of the things my guys learn come from the discussions we have - maybe not exactly on subject, but so what. They're learning and it interests them. What kind of a discussion will you have sitting in front of a computer?

Leroy99: If you build it or they build it or any combination of the two, they are still learning. How many guys in high school can say they built a circular stair? You and Phelps both can. A project like that forces you to use your brain and your hands, a perfect mix.

dorkpunch said...

Just stumbled across your blog. I'm a relatively new "shop" teacher in a state that is "reforming" the education system to be "better". I don't see my job lasting much longer, which is sad on many levels- one being I LOVE my job and another being that the kids get a lot out of being able to think and problem solve all by themselves. Going to be spending some time here gathering bits of wisdom from those more experienced than I in hopes to make myself a better teacher.